Skip to content
Order Now Order Now Reservations Ship Nationwide
Order Now Order Now Reservations Ship Nationwide

Menu may vary based on restaurant.

See Locations for Full Menus
Charred Texture Mozzarella and Tomato sauce pizza

Mozzarella &
Tomato Sauce Pie Local Favorite

 

Made with Sally’s tomato sauce and mozzarella

Charred Texture Tomato sauce pizza

Tomato Sauce Pie Staff Pick

 

Made with Sally’s tomato sauce and parmesan (without mozzarella)

Charred Texture White pizza

White Pie

 

Made with mozzarella and parmesan (without tomato sauce)

Specialty Pies

White pizza with slices of potato and rosemary
Potato &
Rosemary Special Staff Pick

Mozzarella, potato, onion, parmesan, rosemary

Garden pizza with vegetables on top
Garden Special

Mozzarella, fresh tomato, onion, zucchini, basil

White pizza with slices of fresh tomatoes
Fresh Tomato
White Pie

Mozzarella, fresh tomato, basil

White pizza with clam on top
New Haven
Original Clam Pie New Haven Classic

Mozzarella, fresh clams, fresh garlic, parmesan

Top down view of the Insider Pizza
The Insider

Sally’s tomato sauce, diced onion, parmesan

Mozzarella and tomato sauce pizza with oven roasted chicken pieces on top
Fire Bird

Mozzarella, Sally’s tomato sauce, oven roasted chicken, diced sweet and hot peppers, onion

White pizza with oven roasted chicken pieces and calabrian chile sauce
Calabrian
Chile Chicken New Item

White pie, oven roasted chicken tossed with Calabrian chile sauce, diced onion, parmesan peppercorn

More Than Apizza

Menu may vary based on restaurant

Milanese-style Chicken with arugula salad on top 

Chicken
Arugula

 

Milanese-style, arugula, endive, radicchio,
tomato vinaigrette

Charred Texture italian chicken wings on white plate with calabrian chile sauce

Italian
Wings

 

Tossed with Calabrian chile sauce, parmesan peppercorn dip

Charred Texture Rigatoni pasta in vodka sauce with parmesan sprinkled on top 

Rigatoni
Vodka

 

Pepperoni vodka sauce, charred tomato, parmesan

Salads

caprese salad with mozarella, tomato and basil
CAPRESE

Liuzzi mozzarella, Campari tomato, basil, EVOO

wedge salad with tomato and shredded provolone cheese on top
Wedge

Cherry tomato, grated provolone, bacon,
parmesan peppercorn dressing

House Salad on a white plate
House

Green leaf, tomato, onion, shaved parmesan, Italian dressing

Caesar Salad on a white plate
CAESAR

Romaine, parmesan, garlic, croutons,
Caesar dressing

Appetizers

italian chicken wings on white plate with calabrian chile sauce
Italian
Wings

Tossed with Calabrian chile sauce, parmesan peppercorn dip

mixed meats and cheese on tray
MEAT &
CHEESE

Cured meats, dressed mozzarella, aged provolone, stuffed cherry peppers, artichokes

Meatballs and marinara sauce in round cast iron plate
SKILLET
MEATBALLS

Marinara, parmesan

stuffed clams with lemon on top in cast iron round plate
BAKED
CLAMS

Focaccia breadcrumb, Sicilian oregano

Pastas

Ravioli pasta in marinara sauce with parmesan shavings
RAVIOLI
MARINARA

Ricotta, tomato sauce, parmesan

Rigatoni pasta in vodka sauce with parmesan sprinkled on top 
RIGATONI
VODKA

Pepperoni vodka sauce, charred tomato, parmesan

Spaghetti with clams on top in cast iron on white plate
SQUARED
SPAGHETTI

White clam sauce, grilled focaccia

ENTRÉES

Milanese-style Chicken with arugula salad on top 
CHICKEN
ARUGULA

Milanese-style, arugula, endive, radicchio,
tomato vinaigrette

Chicken Parm on a white plate
CHICKEN
PARMESAN

Marinara, mezze rigatoni

spicy shrimp with lemon on the side inside cast iron on white plate
SPICY
SHRIMP

EVOO, garlic, chile, breadcrumb

Sausage and peppers in cast iron on white plate
SAUSAGE &
PEPPERS

Longhini Italian sausage, sweet pepper, onion, charred fennel

Desserts

cannoli pie on white plate
CANNOLI PIE

cannoli chips on white plate with cannoli dip in center
CANNOLI CHIP & DIP

olive oil cake with fresh berries on white plate
OLIVE OIL CAKE

three Tiramisu on a white plate 
TIRAMISU

Cocktails

italian cookie cocktail with large ice cube
ITALIAN
COOKIE

Amaretto, campari, orange

Wooster st. special cocktail with orange slice
WOOSTER
STREET SPECIAL

Bourbon, rye, pineapple

Fire cocktail with lime slice
FIRE

Blanco tequila, cassis, ginger

1938 cocktail with fresh mint leaf
1938

Gin, mint, cucumber

Summer street swizzle cocktail with lemon slice
SUMMER STREET
SWIZZLE

Vodka,
St. Germain, honey

Happy Hour
Monday – Thursday 4:30-7PM
Monday: $5 seasonal & classic Margaritas
Tuesday: Buy one, get one pints & pitchers
Wednesday: Half-priced wine bottles
Thursday: $6 well & frozen cocktails
Menu may vary based on restaurant.

See Locations for Full Menus
Sally's Italian wings, on a white plate
Sally's Caprese Salad, on a white plate
Sally's Stuffed Cams, on a white plate
Sally's Cannoli Pie, on a white plate